Industrial-scale lagoon plans approved despite opposition from 14 villages

    Plans for an industrial-scale lagoon near Upton Pyne have been given the go-ahead, despite the anger of locals and fourteen villages and hamlets joining forces to protest against the scheme. East Devon District Council’s planning committee on Wednesday morning voted to approve plans which would see the construction of a sealed digestate storage facility with a capacity to hold approximately 7.000 cubic metres of liquid digestate (organic fertiliser).


    Plans for an industrial-scale lagoon near Upton Pyne have been given the go-ahead, despite the anger of locals and fourteen villages and hamlets joining forces to protest against the scheme.
    East Devon District Council’s planning committee on Wednesday morning voted to approve plans which would see the construction of a sealed digestate storage facility with a capacity to hold approximately 7.000 cubic metres of liquid digestate (organic fertiliser).
    The scheme would support the operation of the Gorst Biogas Ltd anaerobic digestion plant at Enfield Farm, Clyst St Mary, and the tank facility would store digestate over the farmland winter, but also allow digestate to be spread efficiently and sustainably as an organic fertiliser on the land surrounding it.
    The lagoon will be located on a waterlogged green-field site off Rixenford Lane, which is owned by the Earl of Iddesleigh and served by a narrow, quiet country lane frequented by cyclists and walkers.
    Local villages and hamlets had come together to object to the proposals, as have the Devon CPRE, saying that the expansion of anaerobic digesters (ADs) has to be curtailed to protect rural communities and the countryside as they are currently ‘out of control’.
    The fourteen rural communities who had voiced their concerns by this proposal are Upton Pyne, Brampford Speke, Langford, Shute, Efford, Shobrooke, Newton St Cyres, Thorverton, Rewe, Ratcliffe, Politimore, Huxham, Cowley and Stoke Canon.
    But the applicant Stuarts Partners Ltd had said the scheme supports the sustainability and efficiency of farming operations in the area and that it would not lead to a noticeable increase in traffic.
    Planning officers had recommended that the scheme be approved, and councillors voted in favour of the recommendations by nine votes to three.
    Setting up why officers had backed the plans, Chris Rose, development manager, told the committee that the impact on highway safety is considered acceptable as the vehicle movements associated with the development would not be detrimental to the occupiers of properties in the area and that while the proposal would have a visual impact, lagoons of this type in the countryside are not uncommon features.
    He added: “It is clear that this proposal has generated considerable interest from local residents and other consultees. However, it is considered that, on balance, and subject to conditions, the proposal is acceptable.”
    Agent for the applicant Troy Stuart added that the scheme will save movements from the lagoon to the farm, adding that while it doesn’t change the movements in total, it changes the intensity of them.
    But local resident Sally Doldorph pleaded with the committee to reject the plans, saying ‘the state of several hamlets is in your hands today’, while Cllr Roger Cashmore, on behalf of Newton St Cyres Parish Council added: “Please reject this which only benefits the expansion plant of the AD on the other side of Exeter. Residents are angered and fail to grasp while this is even being considered and we have no confidence the conditions can be relied on or enforced.”
    And Cllr Fabian King, who represents the Exe Valley ward, added: “I have never received such discontent, upset or anger in Exe Valley that I have over this application. There is no genuine agricultural need for this and there is so much opposition to this.”
    Cllr Joe Whibley said that while it appeared there would be little ground to defend a refusal if it went to appeal, ‘this doesn’t feel right, and I completely understand why the residents feel so strongly about this’, while Cllr Olly Davey added: “The suggested the lagoon will make it better, but only an intolerable situation made marginally better by the creation of the lagoon.”
    However, Cllr Philip Skinner said: “What I think the applicant is trying to do is to try and reduce large volumes of traffic in a short window and having it in a much wider window because of the lagoon. The amount of movements won’t change whether we accept this or not, but how we deliver the movements over a longer period of time.
    “In my opinion, I believe the benefits that will come from this is that the impact is likely to be less in volumes in short periods of time over a longer period than not having the lagoon.”
    Cllr Tom Wright said that he understood and sympathise with the concerns expressed but that agriculture is changing and vehicles are much bigger, adding: “However disruptive movements are, the implications are not to significantly increase those movements, so we have very few grounds to object,” while Cllr David Key said: “I cannot see the problem with this. I feel sorry for the people who live there but we have to move on in life and this is part and parcel of farming.”
    Councillors voted by nine votes to three to approve the application, albeit with a condition that the digestate can only be used on enterprises owned by the applicant.

    More from Local News

    • Exmouth RNLI called to rescue crew of sinking fishing vessel

      At 12:07pm today Friday 18 June 2021 the Exmouth RNLI All Weather Lifeboat 13-03 R & J Welburn was tasked by H.M. Coastguard to a report of a male person who had taken to a life-raft after his 40ft fishing boat had started to take on water in Lyme Bay about 6 miles south of Budleigh Salterton.

    • Founder of Exmouth Friends in Need Claire Austin has been Awarded the BEM in the Queens Honours List

      On the 11th June 2021 in the Queen's Honours List Claire Louise Austin was awarded the BEM (British Empire Medal) for services to the community in Exmouth, Devon during Covid-19. Claire Founded Exmouth Friends in Need in 2018.

    • Devon & Cornwall Police Appeal for witnesses

      Police investigating an assault on a man in Exeter are appealing for information to help with their enquiries. Officers were called to reports of an altercation outside St Sidwell’s Chapel, on Sidwell Street, between 3.30pm and 4pm, on Tuesday 15 June.

    • Devon & Somerset Fire Service Explain Information about Digby the Defusing Dog

      Digby is a three year old Labradoodle who volunteers for Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Service supporting the delivery of critical incident defusing. The purpose of defusing is to reduce the risk of developing post-traumatic stress and where necessary, supporting individuals to gain access to counselling or other support.

    • Don’t delay: learn how to save lives

      South Western Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust (SWASFT) is urging people to learn what to do if someone collapses or stops breathing normally. Only around 1 in 10 people survive a sudden cardiac arrest in the UK, although bystanders can make a big difference if they take the right action fast. According to Resuscitation Council UK (RCUK), “every person should learn to provide the basic skills to save a life”.

    • Bodycams to boost ambulance crews’ safety

      South Western Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust (SWASFT) is rolling out body-worn cameras in a bid to reduce violence and aggression against colleagues. All frontline ambulance crews in Cornwall & Isles of Scilly, Devon, Dorset, Somerset, Bristol, Wiltshire and Gloucestershire will be able to wear the cameras, following a significant increase in verbal abuse and physical assaults from patients and other members of the public.

    • Person on a Ride on Mower falls 15ft Over a Bank

      Yesterday at 4pm Devon & Somerset Fire Service received a call to a person in difficulty in Vineycroft Lane, Salcombe Regis. Fire Engines from Ottery St Mary, Colyton and Sidmouth attended an incident following reports of a person on a ride on lawn mower having dropped 15 feet over a bank.

    • Exeter Wild City Bursts into Colour

      Roadside verges, roundabouts and various patches of land in Exeter have broken out in a riot of colour as wildflowers have started to bloom. Wild flower seeds have been sown throughout the city as part of the Wild City project. Wild City – now over ten years old - sees Exeter City Council work closely with Devon Wildlife Trust to encourage nature into the city.


    Tide Times

    Today's Weather

    • Exmouth

      Sunny intervals

      High: 16°C | Low: 9°C

    • Sidmouth

      Sunny intervals

      High: 16°C | Low: 10°C

    • Exeter

      Sunny intervals

      High: 17°C | Low: 9°C

    • Dawlish

      Sunny intervals

      High: 17°C | Low: 11°C

    What's On

    • Exeter Canal Cruise

      Reminisce as you travel through time along the oldest working ship canal in Europe with a choice of departure from Exmouth or Exeter. Sailing through two working locks and the Countess Wear swing bridge, this cruise presents the perfect opportunity to explore the historic quayside of Exeter and enjoy a spot of lunch at one of the many independent eateries.

      at Exmouth Marina
    • Drowning Prevention Day 10am til 4pm

      The Royal Life Saving Society (RLSS) is holding a Drowning Prevention Day hosted by Exmouth National Coastwatch Institution (NCI) and supported by the RNLI at Coastwatch House on Exmouth Sea front. All three organisations will talk about drowning prevention, beach and water safety. There will be free colouring sheets, demonstrations of rescue equipment and quizzes for kids as well as information on local hazards and what to do in an emergency. The Exmouth RNLI Water Safety Team will advise on Lifejackets and show you how to check yours is safe, so bring yours along.

      at The Lookout
    • Bob Crooks - Poetry in Glass Show 10am til 5.30pm

      Steam Gallery is delighted to be hosting an exceptional new show ‘Poetry in Glass’ by Bob Crooks. One of Britain’s most highly recognised glassmakers, Bob is well-known for his original and challenging dynamic forms that exploit the many properties of studio glass. Bob works his glass magic in a studio in deepest Devon, and his output ranges from fine wine glasses to imaginative and elegant sculptural forms. Creating these perfect works requires the highest skill and concentration, especially with the ever-present threat of disaster in this intense complex process! Bob has created a brand-new collection of over 20 unique pieces for this special show. Contact the gallery on 01297 625144 to request a catalogue to be sent to you in advance of the exhibition opening, or request an invite to join for the launch day on Saturday 19 June, when Bob will be present. You can see the pieces online, and all are available to purchase now.

      at Steam Gallery